Pagliacci`s Italian Dining in Mattoon

Reasonably priced n 1 of 2 salad bars in town

Great place to eat and prices are responsible

Pretty basic dinner but nice

Ordered burger bowl, it was a bowl of chili w/o beans⭐ On positive note my husband loves the ham & beans⭐⭐⭐⭐

Always hot and fresh. Tea to thirst for. Good service.

Nice local restaurant. Good food. Reasonably price.

A poorly maintained, dirty place. Food is ok.

My husband & I go every Friday night for the all you can eat catfish and shrimp. The food is fantastic and the staff is very friendly.

Service is passable but lately the food has been lack luster

Friday night prime time pizza buffet--the pizza should have been tossed out an hour before we got there. Was soggy and disgusting, dessert cinnamon sticks were raw dough in the center. I'm not difficult to please on these things, but that was inexcusable. Will not return. Not having enough customers is no excuse to leave food on a buffet until it rots.

Horrible second time I was refused the early bird special a simple lettuce salad no tomato no cheese just lettuce with grilled chicken breast I was forced to order corn and I gave it to my grandma to eat. Leaving the restaurant hungry.

Excellent food and service as always

I have been coming here for only 3 years - always bring my kids and grandkids!nice place - but it does need to be cleaned up!apparently it is the place to be for locals -especially the retired -bit for some reason -they seem to be out of choices on the menu! Went there from tolono to eat 'but out of chicken again! And the staff wasn't At all friendly today! And couldn't have the rib eye with breakfast -but paid more for the same for lunch !I like going there for the their laid back attitude -bur doubt that I will go b k

Well rounded resaurant not to fancy yet still has class

Have never had a bad breakfast, lunch, or dinner here!!! I especially love their hash browns!!!! Very good and cooked to perfection for me! I really enjoy their salad par and pizza bar. Very affordable pricing and exceptional staff! This is a wonderful Family Style Restaurant that has a very extensive menu and offers a variety of items for all appetites! I have to say- they definitely have the best fried chicken in town!!!! LOVE IT!!!!

Great service and food.

This is a good Hometown restaurant has some good menu items that dessert pizza is really good I've been here on a number of occasions the pricing is decent the atmosphere is good you really have a good sense of Family Dining they got nice and friendly staff.

There pizza is great, and they have pretty good service.

Decent lil food joint. They have amazing Italian beef pizza. They also offer pizza buffet every weekend..and they will make whatever pizza u want for the buffet

Great little sit down place! I go about once a week, with my girlfriend! We can't get enough of it!

I have been to Pagliacci's numerous times and have never been disappointed! I think some of these reviewers expect white table clothes and a maitre D on hand to seat them and play the violin while they partake of their eight dollar dinner. Wake up people, this is a local restaurant which serves home cooked cuisine, not a Chicago restaurant with overpriced spaghetti! The only thing I would like different is to post the menu online. Thank you for being there for us who do not desire to drive 200 miles for a meal.

Excellent food and service!

Very good food and prices

Lovely wait staff. Full menu. Great food.

They have pretty good Manhattons

Good food and service

Good is really good. Service is also really good.

The food is ok. They have their days like every restaurant. I have had a variety of different foods there. Sometimes good sometimes not; but waitress staff is nice and I have never been treated bad when I come in with my small service dog. I like this restaurant it's a very friendly and comfortable family place to eat.

We absolutely Love Pagliacci's! The Service and Food is Top Notch!

Love their wings! Fries suck but wings are good

Great food great value friendly staff will go again

Great food and great service...

Great bteakfast food. Fast friendly service and great free WiFi.

The all you can eat fish and shrimp on Friday night is always very good! Come early so as to beat the crowds and are able to get a good seat. The wait staff is always very nice and friendly! 😀

We usually eat here at least once a week and have never had a bad experience. On Fridays they have an all you can eat catfish and shrimp meal that is amazing. The girls who wait on you always greet you with a smile at your table.

Pasta was overdone, sauce was bland, garlic bread should have garlic on it. The side salad consisted of shredded lettuce and two tomato quarters. Very young and inexperienced waitress. Very affordable dinner, but for a very good reason. Stay home and cook dinner yourself, I now wish I had.

Good food great price

Best fried chicken around. Broasted with fantastic light breading. Fantastic salad bar. I love shredded lettuce and they have all the good stuff on the bar, even fresh strawberry's. My waitress was fantastic, returning often to make sure we didn't need any thing. She brought me a tea refill without asking right before I needed one.

Family owned and operated for the last 15 years, hard to accomplish nowadays .

Good food fast service

First and last time visit. Ok food but terrible service

Great lunch menu very good.

Great food great price

The meal I eat before my lunch meeting is always served hot and with smiling friendly service.

The prices are outrageous. Service is slow. 1 friendly worker in the entire restaurant. The waitress said the crispitos was chicken. They weren't. The salad is a joke. & the lettuce was old. The food is ok. Not the best. If I could I would rate it negative stars. Definitely will not be back

good food and service. better than cracker barrel. and you don't have to wait half an hour for a table

The pizza crust is not very good. Good service.

I love the Munchie Mia Cheese Stix, taco pizza, supreme pizza, & salad bar.

Got breakfast delivered and a TON of the dishes were prepared wrong. Gave me ground beef instead of steak, strawberries instead of blueberries, no peppers on the scrambler, and the "toast" was chewy and cold. I normally don't complain about food but this was particularly bad and it took FOREVER. So the food sucked and one of my guests left before their food even got to my house....the delivery driver was very nice though. If it wasn't for him, my rating would be one star.

First time ever trying the place out. While there, a manager was yelling at an employee telling him to work or go home, in essence firing him up front at the top of his lungs. The entire restaurant became very quiet because of the yelling that was going on up front, it was very uncomfortable. Then forgot who had ordered what I had ordered, so I had to wait for a lengthy period of time.